The buy-to-let landscape in the UK has undergone significant changes over the last decade. Tax reforms, regulatory tightening, and fluctuating property prices have left many landlords questioning whether buy-to-let is still a worthwhile investment. Despite these challenges, the market can still be profitable with the right strategy. Here, we’ll explore the current state of buy-to-let and whether it remains a viable option, while also highlighting some attractive alternatives.
Table of Contents
Key Changes in Buy-to-Let
In recent years, several key changes have hit landlords hard. The government introduced a 3% stamp duty surcharge on additional properties in 2016, and in 2020, mortgage interest relief was removed, meaning landlords can no longer deduct mortgage interest from their taxable income. Higher-rate taxpayers, in particular, have been hit with higher tax bills, reducing the profitability of their buy-to-let properties.
This year, the Labour government announced the Renters’ Rights Bill, banning Section 21 'no-fault' evictions and extending Awaab’s Law to the private sector, further increasing the responsibilities of landlords. These regulatory changes add complexity to property management, but for those with the right approach, buy-to-let can still be a valuable source of income.
Fortunately, there are some positive developments. In April 2024, capital gains tax (CGT) on property was cut from 28% to 24% for higher-rate taxpayers, offering some relief when selling properties. Additionally, rental prices have surged, with an average increase of 8.6% between July 2023 and July 2024, providing greater income potential for landlords.
Is Buy-to-Let Still a Profitable Investment?
The answer depends on your investment goals and how well you can navigate the evolving market. While buy-to-let may not offer the same easy profits it once did, there are still opportunities for savvy investors. Some advantages include:
Rental income: In certain areas like Sunderland and Burnley, rental yields are still high, reaching up to 9%. With rents rising faster than house prices, the rental market continues to offer strong income potential.
Capital growth: Property prices, while fluctuating, are expected to rise over time. This means that your buy-to-let investment could appreciate in value, providing a long-term return.
However, there are drawbacks:
Higher tax burden: Since the removal of mortgage interest relief, landlords face higher tax bills, particularly those in higher tax brackets.
Market volatility: Property prices can fall, reducing your capital. If you’re on an interest-only mortgage, you may face a shortfall when it’s time to sell.
Regulatory burden: Managing a property comes with increasing responsibilities, and tougher tenant rights make it harder to evict problematic renters.
Given the changing landscape, is traditional buy-to-let still worth it? For some, the answer is yes, but many are turning to alternatives that can offer better returns or less hassle.
Here’s an example of how the tax situation has changed for a landlord who pays £500 a month in mortgage interest and receives £1,000 a month in rental income:
Prior to 2017 | Since 2020 | |
Annual rental income | £12,000 | £12,000 |
Annual mortgage interest | £6,000 | £6,000 |
Taxable annual income | £6,000 | £12,000 |
Tax credit of mortgage interest | 0% | +20% (£1,200) |
Tax bill (lower rate) | £1,200 | £1,200 |
Tax bill (higher rate) | £2,400 | £3,600 |
Alternatives to Traditional Buy-to-Let
HMO Investment
One of the most popular alternatives to traditional buy-to-let is investing in Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs). HMOs are properties rented out to multiple tenants, typically on a room-by-room basis, which allows landlords to generate significantly higher rental yields compared to single-let properties.
Pros:
Higher rental income: HMOs can generate up to three times the rental income of a standard buy-to-let property, as you’re renting each room individually.
Spreading risk: With multiple tenants, you’re less likely to face void periods where the property is completely unoccupied.
Cons:
Stricter regulations: HMOs are subject to more stringent legal requirements, including licensing, safety standards, and room size regulations.
Higher management costs: Managing an HMO involves more work and potentially higher maintenance costs due to the higher turnover of tenants.
Short-Stay Serviced Accommodation
Another alternative is to convert your property into short-stay serviced accommodation. This model targets tourists, business travellers, and others needing temporary housing, usually through platforms like Airbnb. Short-term rentals can be highly profitable, especially in popular tourist destinations or city centres.
Pros:
Higher income potential: Short-term lets can bring in much more rental income compared to long-term tenancies, especially during peak seasons.
Flexibility: You can choose when to rent your property out and use it yourself during off-peak times.
Cons:
Fluctuating demand: The income from short-stay properties can vary depending on the season and local events. Some months may be highly profitable, while others might bring in little to no income.
Higher running costs: Cleaning, utilities, and the need for furnishings all add to the costs of running short-term accommodation. Managing bookings and guest turnovers can also require more time and effort.
Buy to Sell (Flipping)
For investors who want a quicker return, buy-to-sell, or property flipping, is a popular strategy. This involves purchasing a property at a lower price, often one that needs renovation, and selling it for a profit after making improvements.
Pros:
Potential for quick returns: If you can buy at a discount, renovate effectively, and sell in a rising market, the potential returns can be substantial.
No long-term commitment: Unlike buy-to-let, flipping allows you to exit the investment quickly after the sale, meaning your capital isn’t tied up for years.
Cons:
Market risk: The success of flipping relies heavily on the state of the housing market. If property prices fall, you may not make a profit.
Renovation costs: Unexpected repair costs or delays can eat into your profit margins. It's essential to budget carefully and ensure you have enough capital to cover unforeseen expenses.
Is Buy-to-Let Still Worth It?
Despite the challenges, buy-to-let can still be a rewarding investment for those who approach it with the right strategy and professional guidance. While tax reforms and stricter regulations have made it harder for some landlords to turn a profit, there are still opportunities for those willing to adapt.
Whether you’re considering buy-to-let, HMOs, short-stay accommodation, or property flipping, each investment type comes with its own risks and rewards. The key is to thoroughly research your options, get expert financial advice, and tailor your strategy to suit your personal goals and market conditions.
With careful planning and a solid strategy, buy-to-let remains a viable way to generate income and build wealth over time. At Clarice Carr & Co, we specialise in helping investors navigate the complexities of the property market and find the most profitable opportunities. Get in touch today for personalised advice and guidance tailored to your investment needs.
Want to know more? Check out our website or get in touch.
Commentaires